For solicitors and legal teams

Independent motor engineering evidence for RTA litigation

Independent CPR Part 35 motor engineering opinions for claimant and defendant solicitors, covering RTA and personal injury matters, repair costs, valuations, forensic questions and vehicle damage. We provide physical inspections and desktop reports where the evidence supports them, with the expert's duty to the court coming first.

Independent expertise, regardless of who instructs us

Claimant, defendant or single joint expert
Duty to the court comes first
Evidence-led opinions, not preferred outcomes
CPR Part 35 reports where instructed

Straightforward instructions, with early technical clarity

We understand that proportionality, deadlines and a realistic prospect of obtaining useful evidence matter to legal teams.

Initial triage and scope

For active clients, a brief initial technical view on quantum, total loss, causation or evidential difficulties may be available at no or modest cost, helping decide whether a fuller instruction is proportionate.

Report within the required framework

We agree the questions, any preferred cost matrix, evidence, report requirements and timetable. Desktop and physical reporting options are assessed against the issues.

Support as the case develops

Our engineers can consider CPR Part 35 questions, clarification requests and oral evidence where required. Regular clients can discuss APIs, client-portal access and workflow arrangements.

Technical opinions beyond the standard damage report

Not every motor instruction is a conventional accident repair report. We also consider specialist questions concerning low-velocity impact, the consistency of damage with an alleged collision, possible image manipulation or fraud indicators, accident reconstruction and the diminution in market value arising from accident damage.

Where relevant, our engineers can review issues of subrogation, revised or re-rated estimates and technical differences between competing repair cost positions. These instructions require clear questions and suitable records; they may need specialist examination rather than a routine desktop estimate.

Our valuation work also extends beyond total-loss claims: we can consider cars, vans, motorcycles, classic and prestige vehicles, specialist collections and cherished registration numbers, including valuation questions arising in probate or divorce proceedings. Scope, available comparables and appropriate specialist evidence are agreed case by case.

Independence is essential to credible expert evidence

An independent motor engineering opinion addresses what the available evidence shows, not what the party paying for a report would prefer it to show. Laird works for claimant and defendant solicitors and considers single joint expert instructions. We have no financial interest in whether a repair cost or vehicle valuation is higher or lower, and our engineers must be willing to explain conclusions that do not assist the instructing party.

For CPR Part 35 expert evidence in civil proceedings in England and Wales, the expert's overriding duty is to assist the court on matters within their expertise. That duty takes precedence over any obligation to the instructing solicitor, claimant, defendant or insurer. Reports identify the evidence reviewed, reasoning, alternative explanations, assumptions and material limitations.

Timely accident damage reports can often be prepared from suitable photographs and supporting documents, while physical inspection or further investigation may be essential for hidden damage, repair workmanship, fraud or complex causation questions. A desktop report should not imply that a vehicle has been physically examined when it has not.

We can work to an agreed costs matrix, including appropriate labour rates, paint indices or economic repair thresholds, or refer to recognised industry approaches such as ABP Club guidance where relevant. Such reference points do not replace independent technical judgement. Our experts also have experience of oral evidence in civil and criminal courts and can assist with questions under Part 35 where instructed.

For established solicitor clients, early brief triage on quantum, causation or total loss can sometimes help identify where a case is technically strong, where evidence is missing or where further expenditure may not be proportionate. This is a candid preliminary view, not a promise of any legal outcome.

Questions from RTA and litigation solicitors

Practical guidance on instructions, specialist reports and case progression.

Can Laird act for claimants, defendants or as a single joint expert?

Yes, subject to expertise, availability and any conflict. Independent engineering conclusions are not influenced by which side instructs us. For CPR Part 35 evidence, the expert's overriding duty is to the court.

Are desktop motor engineering reports suitable for litigation?

They can be suitable for issues that can be determined reliably from photographs, repair documentation and other evidence. The report must explain limitations, and some questions require inspection, testing or further evidence.

Can you work to our preferred repair-cost matrix?

Yes. We can apply relevant agreed labour rates, paint indices and economic repair assumptions, or consider recognised industry reference guidance where appropriate, while retaining an independent opinion about the evidence.

Can you value unusual vehicles or cherished registrations?

We can consider instructions involving cars, vans, motorcycles, classics, high-value and specialist vehicles, collections and cherished registration numbers. The appropriate specialist evidence and scope will be agreed for each matter.

Do you provide low-velocity impact, causation or fraud-related reports?

We can assess suitable technical instructions involving damage causation, low velocity impacts, accident reconstruction and disputed or potentially manipulated images. Findings depend on specialist competence, the available evidence and agreed scope.

Can an established client obtain a brief early opinion before commissioning a full report?

For active clients, we can consider a brief triage view on matters such as quantum, total loss or causation, sometimes at no or low cost, before a proportionate full instruction is agreed.

Can your engineers answer Part 35 questions and give oral evidence?

Yes, where appropriate to the instruction. Our engineers have experience of questions to and from experts and of oral evidence in civil and criminal courts, subject to availability and individual competence.

Do you offer integration for volume instructions?

Yes. We can discuss API connections, client-portal access and associated workflow support for firms with regular instructions, subject to the systems and agreed scope.

Need independent engineering evidence for a motor claim?

Tell us the legal questions, available evidence and deadline. We will confirm whether we can assist and the likely scope of work.