Fewer valuation disputes. Less work for claims handlers.
Independent pre-accident vehicle valuations, clear market evidence and a structured route for driver queries can reduce repetitive correspondence without compromising fairness.
Published results from a three-month PAV pilot
Results reported by Laird and Nationwide Accident Hire in October 2026. These are pilot findings, not guaranteed outcomes for other clients.
Almost 75% fewer disputes reaching handlers
Nationwide Accident Hire reported that valuation disputes requiring its internal claims team fell by almost 75% compared with its previous process.
75.4% accepted the original valuation
Of customers who responded during the pilot, 75.4% accepted the initial valuation without challenging it.
95.1% accepted or independently upheld
Of responding customers, 95.1% either accepted their original valuation or had it upheld following independent review.
How an independent PAV process helps
A pre-accident valuation is an evidence-led estimate of a vehicle's market value immediately before the incident. Age, mileage, specification, condition and comparable market information all matter. A fair valuation should be explainable, rather than presented as an unexplained figure.
Valuation disputes can create repeated telephone calls, evidence requests, re-checks and escalations for an accident management company. Laird's approach combines an independent assessment with a clearer explanation for the vehicle owner and a process for reviewing relevant new evidence.
Independence is essential: our responsibility is a fair and reasonable market valuation, not to achieve a predetermined settlement figure. Genuine new evidence may justify revisiting an assessment. The pilot suggests that a transparent, structured process can keep avoidable disputes away from claims handlers while preserving a route for legitimate challenges.
What changes for your operation?
Clearer answers for drivers
Explain relevant comparables and how vehicle details inform the valuation, rather than inviting an unexplained negotiation.
Fewer routine escalations
Handle initial queries and evidence review through an independent valuation process, reducing avoidable internal chasing.
Auditable decisions
Keep a record of the valuation evidence, questions raised and reasons for maintaining or changing a figure.
PAV questions answered
What is a pre-accident valuation?
It is an assessment of the vehicle's market value immediately before the incident, based on its individual characteristics and relevant market evidence.
What evidence can support or change a valuation?
Vehicle specification, mileage, service history, pre-incident condition and genuinely comparable market evidence may be relevant. An asking price alone does not necessarily establish the vehicle's market value.
Does the driver retain the ability to challenge a valuation?
Yes. A structured query process should allow relevant additional evidence to be reviewed and a reasonable correction made when justified.
Does Laird have an interest in reducing the vehicle's value?
No. As an independent motor engineering and valuation business, Laird's role is to arrive at a fair and defensible value supported by evidence.
Will another AMC achieve a 75% reduction in disputes?
No particular result can be guaranteed. The published almost-75% reduction was observed in one three-month client pilot. Outcomes depend on a client's claim mix, baseline process, information quality and implementation.
Can this support be provided alongside our existing claims workflow?
We can discuss operational requirements, instruction volumes, case information and available systems. The scope of integration and communications support is agreed for each client.
Explore a PAV pilot for your claims operation
We can discuss your total-loss volumes, current dispute handling and what an independent valuation process could change.